How to reheat pizza in toaster oven

Do you want your leftover pizza to taste almost as great as it did when it was fresh? Rewarm it in the toaster oven! We’ll walk you through the best temperature and functionality to employ for every toaster oven in this quick step-by-step explanation. It’s so easy (and tasty) that you’ll never eat soggy microwave pizza again.

Let’s start with the temperature. Resist the desire to blast your leftover pizza with high heat unless you want a rock-hard crust and overdone cheese.

Instead, we prefer to progressively warm things up at a lower temperature (325°F). As a consequence, you’ll receive a hot piece of Pizza with melty cheese and a wonderfully crispy crust.

Step by step Guide to Reheat Pizza in a Toaster Oven

  1. To begin, preheat your toaster without food to 425°F (218°C). We discovered that this was the ideal temperature for reheating the Pizza.
  2. Spray your pan with cooking spray to prevent the pizza crusts from adhering to the bottom of the pan. We used a 9 12 by 12 12 inch sheet pan. It fits beautifully into our Hamilton Beach and is easy to clean after each use.
  3. Arrange up to four pizza slices on the baking pan at a time. Avoid stacking to avoid the pizzas from sticking together. If your pan is overcrowded, the cheeses will all melt together, resulting in an unappealing mess.
  4. Leave the pizzas in the toaster oven on medium heat for approximately 5 to 7 minutes, just until the cheese appears as it has remelted.
  5. Take the pizza slices out of the toaster and let them cool. Be careful to use a spatula while serving (it’s just the greatest tool for the task).

So there you have it. These are the steps to making the greatest taste reheated Pizza after trying several approaches. Yes, it’s basic and easy, and it produces the greatest results if you’re ready to wait for them.

How to Reheat a Frozen Pizza in a Toaster Oven

One of the most common issues with reheating frozen Pizza is a wet crust. The following procedure should keep any soggy crust troubles at bay.

Preheat Oven

When reheating a frozen pizza in a toaster oven, we utilize a lower temperature than cooking a frozen pizza. The trick to having delicious reheated frozen Pizza is to warm it rather than toast it.

  • Preheat your toaster to 350°F for thick crust pizza.
  • Preheat your toaster to 275°F for thin-crust Pizza.

Note: Preheating should take around ten minutes.

Preheat A Baking Pan

Put a baking pan in the toaster oven as it warms up if you desire a crispier crust. If you prefer a regular crust, you may skip this step.

Prepare the Slice of Pizza

If you wrapped the Pizza in foil before storing it, you might reheat it in the same foil. If you don’t have any foil, set the pizza pieces on some.

You may now softly spritz the Pizza with wate

r. This keeps the crusts from becoming chewy after warming.

Reheat the Pizza

If you preheated a baking pan without any food, remove it from the oven and place your pizza slices, foil-side down, on the baking pan. Place the baking pan on the center rack of your toaster if it has three or more racks, the bottom rack if it has two racks, or the only rack if it has one rack.


If you did not preheat a baking pan, lay the Pizza straight on the racks in the same manner as instructed above.

Cooking Time

A toaster oven warms frozen Pizza faster than a regular oven. The precise duration may vary depending on the type, but your Pizza should be ready in 3 to 5 minutes.

What is the Best Toaster Oven Functions For Heating Cold Pizza?

how to reheat pizza in toaster oven

Some toasters have more ‘Function’ settings than others. The functions listed below are the best for cooking cold pizza. If your toaster oven does not have the top-rated feature, utilize the one below.

Bake + Convection

Almost all toaster oven comes equipped with

 a bake function. If your toaster oven also has a convection setting, you’ll be pleased with the results.

When the bake option is used in conjunction

 with convection, heated air will flow throughout the oven, ensuring that the pizza crust is perfectly crisp when it is removed.


This feature is ideal for reheating cold pizza since it warms it no longer browning. This reheat function should be able to operate without the need to pre-heat the toaster oven. If your toaster oven has a convection fan, it should be chosen automatically.


Air-Fry options are becoming increasingly common in toaster ovens. This is simply a convection cooking method with a faster fan speed than usual.

If you can perfect the timings, your pizza will turn out beautifully. Because the pizza has been overcooked, it is quite simple to obtain a cardboard-like crust.


Suppose you don’t have access to a convection oven. In that case, we recommend baking the pizza instead but placing a piece of aluminum foil loosely over the top to avoid the cheese and toppings from burning as they heat up throughout the process.


How long does it take to reheat Pizza in a toaster oven?

How long it takes relies on a few things, including how many pieces you’re reheating and how crispy you want your slices. However, it normally takes approximately five minutes. (A single slice may only take three minutes, while four slices may need up to eight.) Keep an eye out for it!

How do you reheat pizza such that the crust stays crispy?

To obtain the best crispiness, use a toaster or, conventional oven, or air fryer. The secret is to cook it for a little bit longer. So, once the cheese has melted and the dish is finished cooking, simply keep it in for another 30 seconds to a minute. Make careful it doesn’t get burned!

What temperature setting should I use to reheat Pizza in a toaster oven?

If you’re using a standard oven instead of a toaster oven, I advise heating the pan in the oven with medium settings (with parchment paper or aluminum foil on top) until it reaches 400F. Then, place your pizza slices on top and cook for roughly five minutes, or until the texture is to your taste.

This approach may be used to reheat any sort of Pizza, whether it is homemade, delivered, or premade. We hope you appreciate your toaster oven and use it to reheat other leftovers as well. We’ve found it to be a highly flexible piece of kitchen equipment.

How should you reheat pizza slices in the oven?

If you’re using a conventional oven instead of a toaster oven, I suggest heating the pan in the oven (with parchment paper or aluminum foil on top) until it reaches 400F. Then, set your pizza slices on top and cook for about five minutes, or until the texture is to your liking.

Read more cooking tips on Pizza here:

I am Chef Harunur Rashid Azim. I inherited my family's love of cooking at a young age. I graduated from the Institute of Culinary Education in London, UK, with determination and passion to become a chef. Follow me on Twitter: @RashidIsChef, FB: Azim

Sharing Is Caring:

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.